Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs Bark: which is best for tradesmen?
There's no single winner between Checkatrade, MyBuilder and Bark. They charge in different ways, and the right one depends on the jobs you want, your area and what your own numbers show.
The question worth asking is: what did I pay to win suitable, profitable work? The platform facts below come from each platform's own pricing pages and terms, checked on 3 November 2026.
The three at a glance
| Platform | How you pay | When you get the customer | Published price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Checkatrade | A monthly membership, with separate fixed-plan and pay-as-you-go lead products | Leads come through a fixed plan or pay-as-you-go; Growth also offers direct booking from search or your profile | Free £0 a month, Approved £30 a month, Growth from £59 a month; pay-as-you-go lead fees vary |
| MyBuilder | A shortlist fee each time a customer's contact details are shared with you | You express interest in a job; details are shared straight away or once the customer confirms you | Shown before you commit, excluding VAT; it depends on the job's likely size, value and location |
| Bark | Credits, with each lead's credit cost shown before you commit | You see the lead and its credit cost, and decide whether to spend credits on it | £1.80 a credit at the standard rate; bigger packs lower the cost per credit |
Checkatrade: membership, plans and pay-as-you-go
Checkatrade's pricing page lists a Free profile (£0 a month), Approved (£30 a month) and Growth (from £59 a month). For Growth you choose your trade, your postcode areas and how many leads you want over a year, and get a fixed monthly price for it. Checkatrade also has separate pay-as-you-go terms, where the fee per lead varies with job value, channel, location, season and demand, and the current range is shown in the Members Area.
The pricing page says fixed-plan memberships are for 12 months. Checkatrade's master terms (updated 13 October 2026) say your confirmation email sets the exact services, fees and contract period, and that the agreement renews automatically for the same length again unless notice is given. To stop it renewing, the business owner phones Checkatrade, no earlier than 35 days before the renewal date. Checkatrade can also raise its fees at renewal with at least 30 days' notice.
Its Fixed Plan terms say any lead estimate is only an estimate and isn't binding. The number of leads depends on your reviews, your locations and your profile, and on things like season and demand. Checkatrade can also stop sending you leads once you reach the estimate.
So check the full commitment, the exact areas covered and whether you're buying a fixed plan or pay-as-you-go leads. Our Checkatrade cost guide walks through the sums.
MyBuilder: pay when contact details are shared
On MyBuilder, customers post jobs and tradespeople express interest. Under MyBuilder's terms for tradespeople, a shortlist fee is due each time a customer's contact details are shared with you after you've expressed interest. Depending on the lead, that happens straight away or once the customer confirms you.
The fee, excluding VAT, is shown before you take any step that could share contact details, and it's worked out from the likely size, value and location of the job. It's non-refundable apart from the specific cases in MyBuilder's terms, and MyBuilder says paying it doesn't guarantee you'll get to quote for or win the work. Shortlist fees are invoiced at least once a week.
One rule to know: MyBuilder's terms don't let you swap contact details with a customer outside the platform, or direct them to your own website, to avoid the fee.
Bark: buy credits, then spend them on leads
Bark shows you leads, and each one's credit cost is shown before you commit. Bark's credit guide (updated 10 June 2026) gives a standard price of £1.80 a credit, with packs lowering the cost per credit. How many credits a lead costs depends on the type of service and the size of the job, and it's shown on the lead before you respond.
Bark's terms say a general request can go to up to 5 professionals and that VAT is added to its fees. They also say Bark won't return credits if the contact details it gave you are correct. Credits bought on or after 1 November 2025 expire 3 months after you buy them.
A worked 90-day comparison
Use your own invoices and results. These figures are made up to show the method; they aren't platform averages or forecasts.
Checkatrade example: a business pays Growth's starting price of £59 a month for three months, gets 12 suitable enquiries and wins three jobs.
- Spend: £59 × 3 = £177
- Cost per enquiry: £177 ÷ 12 = £14.75
- Cost per won job: £177 ÷ 3 = £59
A 12-month plan from £59 a month is about £708 at the published starting price, before any limited-time offer, so the whole contract still matters.
MyBuilder example: the account shows a £20 shortlist fee (excluding VAT) on each of nine jobs you're shortlisted for, and two become paid work.
- Shortlist fees: £20 × 9 = £180 excluding VAT
- Cost per won job: £180 ÷ 2 = £90 excluding VAT
The £20 is made up; use the fee shown before each shortlist.
Bark example: a lead costs 12 credits at Bark's standard £1.80. You contact eight leads and win two jobs.
- Cost per lead: 12 × £1.80 = £21.60, plus VAT
- Total: £21.60 × 8 = £172.80, plus VAT
- Cost per won job: £172.80 ÷ 2 = £86.40, plus VAT
The 12-credit lead is made up too. Use each lead's credit cost and your own pack price. Profit also depends on the value of the job and your direct costs.
What to measure before you choose
For every enquiry, note the platform, whether it was suitable, whether you quoted and won, the revenue and roughly what the job made you after labour and materials. Then work out:
- Cost per suitable enquiry: what you spent on the platform ÷ suitable enquiries
- Cost per quote: spend ÷ quotes sent
- Cost per won job: spend ÷ paid jobs won
- What's left: what the won jobs made you − the platform spend
Compare at least one full buying cycle, and keep each platform's renewal or credit-expiry dates where you can see them.
Where your own website and Google profile fit
Trade platforms can fill gaps in the diary or test a new service. Your own website and Google profile are another way for customers to find you. That route has costs and competition too: Google decides rankings, and no SEO or advertising can promise leads. What a site on your own domain does give you is more control over how your services, work and reviews come across, and over how enquiries reach you. The aim is a healthier mix of sources, not cancelling every platform on principle.
SwiftLead's managed plan is £149 a month, with no setup fee: your website, your Google profile looked after (posts, photos and review replies), 4 blog posts a month on your site, a monthly report and missed-call text-back where your phone setup allows it. There's a 3-month minimum, then 30 days' written notice. That's £447 over the minimum term (3 × £149) and £1,788 over the first 12 months (12 × £149). The website and the words we write stay SwiftLead's and stop when your service ends; your logo, your own photos, your Google profile and your information stay yours (see our terms). It's a managed service, not a number of leads, and our terms say we don't promise rankings, calls, enquiries, reviews, sales or any other result. Confirm the final amount and VAT on your written quote before you compare it with a platform invoice.
A sensible way to buy
Set a test budget your margins can carry, choose the services and areas you want, and decide up front what result would justify carrying on. Ask every new enquiry how they found you, and match the source to the paid job.
Weighing up a website too? Our guide to the best website builder for tradesmen compares the main options honestly.
Official sources checked on 3 November 2026
- Checkatrade pricing, plans, prices and the 12-month membership note
- Checkatrade Master Service Terms, last updated 13 October 2026
- Checkatrade Fixed Plan Product Terms, last updated 19 December 2024
- Checkatrade Pay As You Go Product Terms, last updated 20 February 2026
- MyBuilder terms and conditions, shortlist fees, clauses 10 and 12
- Bark credit guide, updated 10 June 2026
- Bark terms and conditions, professional terms, last updated 1 November 2025